When a fair trial is simply not enough
Monday 25 August 2008 at 13:08 BST
I know that morality is seen by many as an elastic concept. And I accept that in times of civil and military strife, compromises are occasionally made that offend common decency.
In the case of the Levant, Israel has for decades occupied lands belonging to the Palestinians. And a fair number of those Palestinians would like to see every single Jewish man, woman and child driven into the Mediterranean Sea.

Prisoner releases are part of the healing and reconciliation process in such situations. And, difficult though it may be to accept, some of those freed from prison may be psychopathic killers. I don’t know about the 198 Palestinians released today from Israeli jails, but with Samir Qantar, at liberty since June of this year and hero-worshipped for far longer, there is no doubt as to this man’s state of human being.
That makes it all the more disgusting to read the following, taken from a BBC News report of today’s prisoner releases:
“Mrs Haran was able to see the exchange taking place in the distance on the Lebanese border as she laid flowers on the northern Israeli beach where, according to eyewitnesses and the court verdict, Qantar shot her husband in front of her daughter, and went on to smash in the little girl’s head.” [my emphasis]
Can you imagine what the public reaction would be to a British journalist writing about Myra Hindley and Ian Brady’s “alleged” murder of three children in the 1960s? In the Israeli context, “allegedly” would be a more efficient way of saying “according to eyewitnesses and the court verdict”.
If the verdict of an Israeli court was that Qantar shot two men in front of a four year-old child, and then proceeded to crush the little girl’s head with his rifle stock, then surely we have to accept that is what happened. Unless, that is, evidence is presented to an appeal court which leads to the conviction being overturned.
So what’s with the BBC form of words?
In an interview for al-Manar TV, Qantar is reported to have said:
“Allah willing, I will get the chance to kill more Israelis.”
I guess that no longer being in prison increases that chance significantly; the will of “Allah” is completely irrelevant.







